Be prepared for the ultimate appetizer idea: this copycat Mushrooms Neptune recipe inspired by The Keg Steakhouse has a cream cheese, crab and shrimp filling you’re gonna die for!
Don’t you wish you could make some of your favourite restaurant dishes from home? This week, I decided to recreate one of my favourite appetizers from The Keg Steakhouse, scouring the Internet for a close and easily re-creatable recipe. After pulling a few different ones together and doing a lot of taste-testing (such a hard job, right?!?), I think I have created the perfect creamy, indulgent Keg Mushrooms Neptune recipe to enjoy at home!
And you wanna know the best part about this recipe?
You can make the cream cheese filling ahead of time and freeze it to use for another time. I’ve done this so many times and it’s a great way to have a savoury, delicious snack at the last minute. Just imagine opening up the freezer and discovering that half the recipe’s already done for you. It’s a good feeling.?
If you’re making these for a party, you can also make the mushrooms ahead of time and reheat them in the oven by the time company comes. These Mushrooms Neptune are one of my new favourites and a classic appetizer that is a real crowd-pleaser.
You honestly don’t even know how many times family and friends ask me to bring this Mushrooms Neptune dish to parties and gatherings. Or how many ask for the recipe and recreate them at home. All you have to do is say you’re bringing Mushrooms Neptune to a party and everyone’s faces light up and they start licking their lips. Really, I’m doing an actual impression here hahaha.
I think I’ve made these mushrooms maybe about a billion times?
So, let’s get down to it. All you need is the following:
- Button mushrooms
- A gluttonous array of Swiss, parmesan and cream cheese
- Some crab and shrimp
- Green onions
But making these of course is the fun part!
While these Mushrooms Neptune won’t be swimming in sauce like the real Keg version, this recipe as about as close as you will get to this delicious appetizer. I am not even opposed to serving them alongside a steak just like they do at The Keg, but they also work great as a super yummy snack (hello football season or movie night!)
Basically, any chance I get to make these babies I’m taking it.
Trust me, as if I haven’t said it enough yet, these Mushrooms Neptune are sure to become a hit at your next party!
Now if you’re unsure of where to get the crabmeat, I usually buy the imitation crab at the seafood counter because it’s more mild tasting without a strong seafood flavour and it’s CHEAP. However, you can also get canned crab – that works too.
I am all for saving money over here, people.
However, you could definitely splurge too and get the real deal, fresh crab – just make sure it’s high quality if you’re gonna be paying that much. I also like to save time by buying my shrimp pre-cooked so all you have to do is mince it up alongside the crabmeat and green onions, but you can also boil raw shrimp for 2-3 minutes until just cooked and then cut it up once cooled.
From there, mix together all the cheese, sour cream, green onions, crab and shrimp, and you’re on your way to stuffed mushrooms heaven. Honestly, if you eat stuffed mushrooms any other way, you’re missing out!
After you’ve prepared the cream cheese filling, pipe it into a large resealable bag (freeze or refrigerate it if you’re making them later), cut a whole in the bottom of the bag, then pump as much filling as your heart desires into each sautéed mushroom cap.
Now be prepared to be the hero of your next party.
And if you’re looking for more fun finger food recipes, here are a couple of my other favourites. For parties. Or, you know, casual snack time:
Will you be trying this Mushrooms Neptune recipe? I’d love to hear what you cook up in the comments!